Home Contracts Just Hit a 25-Year Low. Mortgage Rates Are Falling Anyway.
Five minutes, once a week. Everything in national real estate that touches your money, and nothing that doesn't.
Signed contracts fell off a cliff
What's happening: NAR's Pending Home Sales Index landed at 66.0 for September, down 7.3% from August and 11.3% from a year ago. Economists polled by Reuters had expected a 0.5% dip. All four regions fell, the West hardest at 9.2%.
Why: That is the lowest reading since the index began in 2001. Lawrence Yun put it on rates: "Market conditions weakened in September due to fast-rising mortgage rates."
What it means for you: Pending sales are contracts signed, so they lead closings by a month or two. November and December closing numbers are going to look rough. If you are selling into that, price for the market you are actually in.
Rates came down. Three weeks running.
What's happening: Freddie Mac's November 5 survey put the 30-year fixed at 7.18%, down from 7.24% the week before and 7.40% two weeks before that. The 15-year fixed slipped to 6.57%. The 10-year Treasury closed at 4.93% on November 3, down from 5.08% in mid-October.
Why: Sam Khater called it a "downward trajectory," crediting an improving environment for buyers "against a backdrop of strong economic growth."
What it means for you: A year ago the 30-year averaged 6.22%, so nobody should be throwing a parade. But 22 basis points off the peak is real money, and the buyers who went quiet in September are the ones who have not noticed yet.
The Fed held, and two people voted to raise anyway
What's happening: On October 28 the FOMC left the target range at 3.75% to 4.00% in a 10-2 vote. Beth Hammack and Lisa Cook both dissented in favor of a quarter-point increase. The statement upgraded its description of the expansion from "solid" to "strong."
Why: Chair Kevin Warsh noted inflation has run above the Committee's target "for close to 6 years." CME FedWatch had December hike odds at 78% after the meeting.
What it means for you: A hold is not a pivot. Two governors wanted to go up, and the market is pricing another increase before the year ends. Anyone telling you to wait for cheap money in the spring is guessing.
The oil story is a housing story
What's happening: WTI crude is trading just above $100 a barrel, up roughly 78% so far this year. Warsh flagged that energy prices "have moved higher again in recent weeks."
Why: Energy feeds inflation, inflation feeds Treasury yields, and Treasury yields are what mortgage rates actually follow. The chain is boring and it is also the whole mechanism.
What it means for you: If you want to know where rates go next, watch the pump, not the Fed's calendar.
Still the most inventory in six years
What's happening: September existing-home sales ran at a 3.99 million annual pace with a median price of $417,500. Unsold inventory sat at 1.60 million homes, the highest since November 2019, at 4.8 months of supply.
Why: In Yun's words, "supply is not really an issue anymore." Demand is the constraint.
What it means for you: Choice and leverage on one side, a shrinking buyer pool on the other. Both things are true at once, which is why the advice depends entirely on which side of the table you are sitting at.
Bottom Line
Contracts at a 25-year low and rates easing for three straight weeks is a contradiction only if you expect the market to turn on a dime. It does not. September's damage was done at 7.40%, and the relief since has not reached anyone's decision-making yet. Watch the October existing-home sales release on November 12 for the first read on whether falling rates bought back any demand.
What This Looks Like in Denver
DMAR's November 4 report, on October data: 2,748 homes closed, down 8.58% from September and 23.54% from last October. New listings fell 16.70% month over month and 9.02% year over year, while active listings still hover around 13,000, up 3.87% from a year ago. The median close price for detached homes was $645,000, up 1.57% from September and down 0.64% year over year. Attached came in at $375,000, up 2.74% for the month and down 3.25% for the year. Year to date, the detached median sits at $650,000, exactly where it landed in 2025 and in 2024.
The number that tells you the most is not a price. Sixty-five percent of October sales involved a seller concession, averaging $12,557. That is the discount hiding behind a median that looks flat.
Underneath it, two different markets. Detached homes went in a median 26 days, four days faster than a year ago, at 98.55% of list. Attached homes took 48 days, up 17.07% year over year, closed at 97.69% of list against 98.17% a year ago, and are sitting on more than seven months of supply. Committee chair Amanda Snitker put it plainly: "Fear continued to influence decisions in the Denver Metro real estate market throughout October." Price for that, and you still sell. Price for last spring, and you join the pile.


Comments